Freud Painting
(25.10.12) All this is about reporting pictures of child (sex)abuse. As we have seen with the accusations against Jimmy Saville, when ‘art’, artists and celebrities are involved it is easier to sweep it all under the carpet. A child pornographic picture is then to be considered ‘art’ and admired, and anybody who would have another opinion will be ignored. If someone less famous had been behind this picture he would long ago been in jail.
I will not print the picture here. On my website I do not present child pornographic pictures or pictures describing mental cruelty to children. But this is the text from the museum catalogue for the recent Lucian Freud exhibition: http://www.npg.org.uk/freudsite/exhibition.htm
LARGE INTERIOR, PADDINGTON
Freud explores the use of a high viewpoint in this portrait of his young daughter, Ib Boyt. She looks vulnerable, lying semi-naked in a foetal position. An overgrown plant towers above her. It has shed some of its dead leaves on to the paint-spattered floorboards. Her father’s presence is felt in the shape of the shabby jacket that hangs behind his daughter. An older Ib appears again later in the exhibition.
Oil on canvas, 1968-9
From: Lars Petersson [mailto:lars…..ail.com]
Sent: 26 April 2012 08:09
To: TEATHER, Sarah
Subject: abusive picture of a distressed child
Dear Sarah Teathers,
I am sure that you as the government’s responsible minister for the well being and protection of children (also against sexual abuse) will consider the following as serious and disturbing as I do myself. It is my hope that you will act accordingly. Last week I reported this to the police:
Recently (I cannot recall the exact day) I visited the London National
Portrait Gallery’s Lucian Freud Portrait exhibition. To my absolute
horror I found there a picture which, I presume, had it been presented
in any other circumstances than obviously an art gallery, would have
been subject to serious criminal investigation. As the art gallery
describes it themselves upon my wife’s complaint to them (She wrote: “I
was completely horrified by the painting of a semi naked child on a bare
floor in a stressed position with ‘evidence of the father’s presence”.):
“The painting depicts Lucian Freud’s daughter Isobel Boyt. She recalled
the experience of sitting for this portrait in Jake Auerbach’s film
‘Lucian Freud Portraits’, and here she spoke of the hours of boredom in
the sittings for this painting. Later she looked back on the experience
fondly, and as a woman sat for her father again in other paintings….”
(also in similar position, I understand…)
On your Metropolitan Police website I read the following:
“Non-photographic child sexual abuse images (drawings and
computer-generated imagery) hosted in the UK Don’t ignore it, report it!
This text immediately concerned the web, but it cannot be more
acceptable to depict/paint a stressed naked child – who had posed for
hours in this way for her own father – in a famous art gallery. Or can
it? I am well aware of legislation around the issue of indecent,
pornographic pictures (photographs) of children. I know the possession
of such child pornography – for example down loaded on a computer – is
illegal and will be prosecuted. My question is: is the possession of a
(highly professional) painted picture (portrait) of a specific, named
child – lying with naked bottom in a stressed position on a bare floor
in – as described, and obvious for the viewer – the ‘presence of her
father’, different? And, if so, why? I understand that an ‘artistic’
photograph of a child in that position would have been considered as
outright child abuse and child pornography and that even the possession
of such picture would be illegal and subject to prosecution. Therefore,
my next question is: does that go for a painting as described as well, or is painted art
above the law? If one painter is allowed to paint his child in that
position for hours, where will the law and the prosecution service draw
the line for who is not to be allowed to do the same? Who is to be
charged for child abuse and who not? After coming across this case I am
very upset and would be very grateful if you would advice me of the
police’s opinion and also advice what next step you intend to take.
Looking forward to your response to this. It is my absolute conviction
that this image should be removed from the exhibition immediately and be
confiscated by Scotland Yard. For the benefit of child protection I hope
you agree. The message must be clear. Stop sexual abuse of children.
Nobody must be above the law.
Sincerely
Lars G Petersson
…………………………….
I got following response. May I say, I do not think that I should have to argue more why I think a picture like that constitutes child abuse – not only in showing it on public display, but also having in mind that it has taken hours to paint – and, in that respect, even worse, the painter was known for having his objects ‘sitting’ even while he painted the back grounds. My question to you, as minister for children, is: will you take this seriously and will you dare declare that not even art is above the law? Letting pictures like that pass for art is, in my opinion, to let children down. It is giving the message that such behaviour towards a child is acceptable – people even pay to come and see the result of it.
_______________________________________________________________
Dear Mr Petersson
We are in receipt of your complaint against the portrait by Mr Freud.
You described the image as of a semi-naked child in stressed position.
I have looked up the relevant legislation on the Police Legal database
and enclose it here.
” Q1. Where can I find the new offence?
The offence is defined at section 62 of the Coroners and Justice Act
2009. (ref: section 62)
Q2. What images does the new offence of possession of prohibited images
of children capture?
The offence aims to capture non-photographic visual depictions of child
sexual abuse.
To meet the terms of the offence a prohibited image must:
a) be pornographic
b) depict one or more of a list of proscribed acts
c) be grossly offensive, disgusting or otherwise of an obscene nature
A prohibited ‘image’ does not include an indecent photograph, or
indecent pseudo-photograph of a child, nor tracings or derivatives of
such photographs and pseudo-photographs. (ref: section 62(1) – (8))
Q3. What is meant by the term ‘pornographic’?
The first element of the offence is an objective test for the jury that
the material was pornographic, which means it must reasonably be assumed
to have been produced solely or principally for the purposes of sexual
arousal. This test should eliminate most works of art, news and
mainstream documentary programmes and films from prosecution. (ref:
section 62(3))”
Whilst this is not exhaustive for it to be investigated it would need to
first meet the above test.
Second it must be on the above list. Please find enclosed section of act
“62(6) An image falls within this subsection if it –
(a) is an image which focuses solely or principally on a child’s
genitals or anal region, or
(b) portrays any of the acts mentioned in subsection (7).
62(7) Those acts are –
(a) the performance by a person of an act of intercourse or oral sex
with or in the presence of a child;
(b) an act of masturbation by, of, involving or in the presence of a
child;
(c) an act which involves penetration of the vagina or anus of a child
with a part of a person’s body or with anything else;
(d) an act of penetration, in the presence of a child, of the vagina or
anus of a person with a part of a person’s body or with anything else;
(e) the performance by a child of an act of intercourse or oral sex with
an animal (whether dead or alive or imaginary);
(f) the performance by a person of an act of intercourse or oral sex
with an animal (whether dead or alive or imaginary) in the presence of a
child. ”
And
“Q4. Are ‘grossly offensive, disgusting or otherwise of an obscene
character’ intended to be three separate concepts, any one of which
could satisfy the requirements of the offence?
Grossly offensive, disgusting or otherwise of an obscene character are
not intended to be read as three separate concepts. ‘Grossly offensive’
and ‘disgusting’ are examples of ‘an obscene character’ and not
alternatives to it. They are drawn from the ordinary dictionary
definition of ‘obscene’ and are intended to convey a non-technical
definition of that concept. (ref: section 62(c))”
I am not sure from your description that the image falls under the above
criteria.
Are there any act of the above proscribed acts shown in the painting?
In the absence of further I would suggest that the first port of call
might be to discuss the matter with the staff at the National Portrait
Gallery.
If, however, the painting does meet all the criteria above then the
Police would be happy to investigate.
Thank you for taking the time to raise this with us and should you have
any further queries please let us know.
City of Westminster & Royal Parks IBO
…………..
Looking forward to your response. I will welcome immediate action and investigation into this matter.
Sincerely
Lars G Petersson
______________________________________________
From: omar.deedat@parliament.uk
To: lar@il.com
Subject: RE: abusive picture of a distressed child
Date: Thu, 26 Apr 2012 13:02:31 +0000
Dear Lars Petersson,
Thank you very much for your email to Sarah Teather MP. Sarah has asked me to reply and to thank you for drawing her attention to this issue.
Sarah would be happy to raise your concerns but would first ask you to confirm your postal address in the constituency. We will then be able to make the necessary enquiries on your behalf.
I look forward to hearing from you.
Best wishes,
Omar Deedat
Head of Office
Tel: 020 8459 0455
Fax: 020 8830 3280
Office of Sarah Teather, Member of Parliament for Brent Central
Minister of State for Children and Families
_________________________________________________
From: Lars Petersson [mailto:larscom]
Sent: 26 April 2012 17:06
To: DEEDAT, Omar
Subject: RE: abusive picture of a distressed child
Dear Mr Deedat,
I do not address Ms Teather in a capacity of residency in her constituency. I address her as minister responsible for children in this country. I expect this to be looked at in the interest of child protection. Who is allowed to abuse children, by having them pose half naked on the floor, and who not? Is art above the law?
Sincerely
Lars G Petersson
________________________________________________
Dear Lars,
Thank you for your email to Sarah Teather MP. As your message relates to Sarah’s role as a Minister in the Department for Education rather than as constituency MP I have forwarded your message to Sarah’s ministerial office who will ensure that it is dealt with by the relevant Minister in the Department.
Omar Deedat
Head of Office
Office of Sarah Teather, Member of Parliament for Brent Central
Minister of State for Children and Families
___________________________________________________
From: lars………mail.com
To: omar.deedat@parliament.uk
Subject: RE: abusive picture of a distressed child
Date: Thu, 26 Apr 2012 23:29:50 +0200
Thanks Omar,
Looking forward to hearing what action Sarah will take.
Kind regards
Lars
_________________________________________
From: Unmonitored.ACCOUNT@education.gsi.gov.uk
To: lars…………com
Subject: Acknowledgement of Case Transfer (Case Ref: 2012/0024786)
Date: Wed, 2 May 2012 10:38:13 +0100
Dear Mr Petersson
Thank you for your correspondence. Please be aware that we have passed on your comments to the Home Office for them to provide an answer. Contact details are as follows:
Home Office……….
Regards
Jayne Watson
From: PS, Teather-DIARY
Sent: 26 April 2012 18:08
To: MINISTERS
Cc: WOODWARD, Carol
Subject: RE: abusive picture of a distressed child **Carol confirmed not referral case as child not at risk**
TO please – Carol, I don’t regard this as urgent but let me know if you disagree!
Alistair Kelsey
Assistant Diary Manager and Correspondence Officer
Private Office of Sarah Teather MP
Minister of State for Children and Families
______________________
From: Unmonitored.ACCOUNT@education.gsi.gov.uk
To: larsgpetersson@hotmail.com
Subject: Acknowledgement of Case Transfer (Case Ref: 2012/0024786)
Date: Wed, 2 May 2012 10:38:13 +0100
Dear Mr Petersson
Thank you for your correspondence. Please be aware that we have passed on your comments to the Home Office for them to provide an answer. Contact details are as follows:
Home Office
Direct Communications Unit
2 Marsham Street
London
SW1P 4DF
Telephone General Enquiries x 020 7035 4848
Textphone: x 020 7035 4742
Fax: 020 7035 4745
Email: public.enquiries@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk
Regards
Jayne Watson
______________________________________________________
From: larscom
To: public.enquiries@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk
Subject: FW: Acknowledgement of Case Transfer (Case Ref: 2012/0024786)
Date: Sun, 3 Jun 2012 14:12:02 +0200
Dear Sir/Madam,
Any news? Have heard nothing from you since the case was transferred.
Sincerely
Lars G Petersson
___________________________________________________________
From: Lars Petersson [mailto:lars.com]
Sent: 08 June 2012 09:54
To: Public Enquiries (CD)
Subject: FW: Acknowledgement of Case Transfer (Case Ref: 2012/0024786)
once more and maybe I will get a reply
________________________________________________________________
Subject: RE: Acknowledgement of Case Transfer (Case Ref: 2012/0024786)
Date: Fri, 8 Jun 2012 11:34:20 +0100
From: Public.Enquiries@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk
To: lars@om
Dear Correspondent,
I can confirm that we have received your email, and have passed it on for attention in due course.
Public Enquiries Duty Officer
Communications Directorate
Home Office, 2 Marsham Street, London SW1P 4DF
Tel: +44 (0)20 7035 4732
—–Original Message—–
From: public.enquiries@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk
To: lars@com
Subject: FW: Mr L G Peterson-SPPU-Acknowledgement of Case Transfer (Case Ref: 2012/0024786)
Date: Mon, 18 Jun 2012 14:58:53 +0100
Mr L G Peterson,
Reference : T8216/12
Date: 18-Jun-2012
TREAT OFFICIAL CORRESPONDENCE
Thank you for your e-mail of 13/06/2012 11:42:42 AM regarding…..
The matters you have raised are the responsibility of Ministry of Justice.
We have therefore transferred your e-mail to
general.queries@justice.gsi.gov.uk, who will arrange for a reply to be
sent to you.
Transfer Desk
(isn’t it great, they even have a “transfer desk” to do the job, get rid of anything difficult. Sir Humpfrey would have been envious….. From that on I have heard nothing more…. It was transfered to oblivion. Probably the same as some people hoped for would happen with the accusations against the discjockey Saville. I wonder: why?)














